Making power is but one variable in going fast. The upper echelon of performanceâ€”occupied by the mega-output Germans, big-muscled Corvettes and Hellcats, and, of course, Italian exoticaâ€”now depends on automatic transmissions, launch control, track-bred tires, and often all-wheel drive to generate stupefying performance.
That same phenomenon is just beginning to play out in our beloved hot-hatch segment, a first step on the factory-hot-rod ladder onto which go-fast technology slowly but surely trickles. With the spiciest hatchbacks making roughly 300 horsepower, the major players have turned to all-wheel drive to provide some relief to the front tires. In our May 2016 issue, the Ford Focus RS claimed the belt by defeating the Volkswagen Golf R and the Subaru WRX STI (okay, the Subaru isnâ€™t a hatch, but it should be one).
Honda, however, still sees merit in the original front-wheel-drive formula. The companyâ€™s new Civic Type R, imported to the U.S. for the first time in the nameplateâ€™s 20-year history, suggests that lighter weight and a lower price are enough to offset the straight-line traction advantage of all-wheel drive. To see if that notion has merit, weâ€™ve pitted the Type R against the reigning champ in a battle of turbocharged four-cylinder hatchbacks. The Hondaâ€™s 2.0-liter produces 306 horsepower to the 2.3-liter Fordâ€™s 350.
The single-spec Type R goes for $34,775; its equipment list includes satellite radio, a proximity key, and dual-zone climate control. Navigation, audio, and some climate controls run through a standard seven-inch touchscreen, while the only transmission, a six-speed manual, keeps the turbocharged Type R tethered to the analog world. Hondaâ€™s Type R adheres to the simpler, original hot-hatch formula with just one modern assist: a rev-matching algorithm that will blip the throttle on downshifts. We prefer to turn it off for the challenge and satisfaction of heel-and-toe downshifting.
Fordâ€™s Focus RS will soon end its three-year production run with 1500 special-edition 2018 models that add a limited-slip front differential and a black roof among other cosmetic tweaks. Our tester is not that car. Instead, we have a $36,995 Focus RS with the $2785 RS2 package, which adds heated seats, a heated steering wheel, a power driverâ€™s seat, and navigation. RS buyers can also spend $1990 on Michelin Pilot Sport Cup 2 tires that are best reserved for track use. Our comparo contender is shod with the standard street-friendly Michelin Pilot Super Sport rubber.
We relocated to Pennsylvaniaâ€™s Allegheny National Forestâ€”due north of the Westmoreland factory where Volkswagen sparked the hot-hatch movement 34 years ago by building the first GTIs for the United Statesâ€”to pick a winner, and then struggled to do exactly that.
Read more on Car and Driver.